EB2 · ADVANCED DEGREE AND EXCEPTIONAL ABILITY
Understand advanced degree and exceptional ability qualification, permanent employer sponsorship, PERM certification, Schedule A and the national interest waiver option.
Qualifications, the employer's actual job requirements and the applicable labor certification route must support the petition together.
NIW offers a separate EB2 option for qualified applicants whose proposed endeavor meets the national interest waiver standard.
SECOND PREFERENCE EMPLOYMENT BASED IMMIGRATION
EB2 provides immigrant classification for members of the professions holding advanced degrees and for individuals with exceptional ability in the sciences, arts or business. Qualification under one of these classifications is only part of the analysis. The petition must also satisfy the applicable job offer and labor certification requirements or establish a valid exception.
For the ordinary employer sponsored route, the employer, permanent position, recruitment record and beneficiary qualifications must align. A separate national interest waiver route may dispense with the job offer and labor certification when its additional standards are met.
Discuss an EB2 petitionELIGIBILITY FRAMEWORK
EB2 is not awarded merely because an applicant holds a graduate degree or has a distinguished career. The classification and filing route must be established separately.
The individual must be a member of the professions holding a US advanced degree or foreign equivalent, or a qualifying bachelor's degree followed by at least five years of progressive post degree experience in the specialty.
For a labor certification or Schedule A petition, the offered position must itself require an advanced degree professional, and the beneficiary must meet its minimum requirements by the relevant filing date.
The person must possess expertise significantly above that ordinarily encountered in the sciences, arts or business. Initially, evidence must satisfy at least three of six regulatory categories, followed by USCIS review of the record as a whole.
The beneficiary must also meet the applicable employment and labor certification requirements unless an appropriate exception or waiver applies.
ADVANCED DEGREE QUALIFICATION
The analysis considers the credential, field, professional occupation and the minimum requirements of the offered job.
A US degree above the bachelor's level or a qualifying foreign equivalent may establish the advanced degree credential. Foreign degree equivalency and professional requirements require examination.
A US bachelor's degree or foreign equivalent followed by at least five years of progressive post baccalaureate experience in the specialty is treated as the equivalent of a master's degree for classification purposes.
For standard employer sponsored petitions, the certified position must require an advanced degree or its regulatory equivalent. A worker's master's degree alone cannot convert an ordinary bachelor's level position into EB2.
8 CFR 204.5(k)(3)(ii)
Applicants generally submit documentation satisfying at least three of these six categories. USCIS subsequently evaluates the evidence as a whole to determine whether the individual has expertise significantly above the ordinary level in the field.
An official academic record showing a degree, diploma, certificate or similar award from an institution of learning relating to the area of exceptional ability. Show the relationship of the qualification to the claimed field.
Letters from current or former employers documenting at least ten years of full time experience in the occupation. The letters should establish dates, position, responsibilities and the nature of the work.
A license to practice the profession or certification for the occupation, supported by information establishing its relevance, requirements and validity.
Evidence of compensation for services that demonstrates exceptional ability. Comparative compensation information can explain why the remuneration is significant in the relevant occupation and location.
Document membership and describe the association's professional purpose, admission conditions and standing. The criterion does not automatically require the restrictive achievements based membership test used in EB1A.
Recognition for achievements and significant contributions to the industry or field by peers, governmental entities or professional or business organizations. Independent evidence of the work's effect is often more persuasive than general endorsements.
EMPLOYER SPONSORSHIP
Most EB2 cases use an employer sponsored permanent job offer. The employer must establish genuine minimum requirements and the beneficiary's qualifications for the particular certified role.
Confirm that duties, minimum education, experience, alternatives and any special requirements reflect the employer's real business needs and support the chosen EB2 classification.
Degree documents and employment verification should establish that the worker met the position's requirements when required, generally by the labor certification filing date for PERM petitions.
For petitions requiring a job offer, the employer must generally demonstrate the ability to pay the proffered wage from the priority date until the beneficiary obtains permanent residence under 8 CFR 204.5(g)(2).
STANDARD EMPLOYER SPONSORED ROUTE
Most ordinary EB2 employer petitions require a Department of Labor labor certification before Form I-140. A permanent job offer must meet the applicable recruitment and labor market requirements.
Assess minimum qualifications, actual duties, job location, business necessity where applicable and whether the position supports EB2 rather than EB3.
Obtain the required prevailing wage determination from the Department of Labor and ensure the offered wage and intended role are consistent with the PERM plan.
Complete the required recruitment and consider applicants according to the governing rules. The employer should maintain complete records of each required recruitment step.
File the labor certification application after the prescribed steps. Audits, supervised recruitment and application defects may affect eligibility and timing.
After approval, timely submit Form I-140 with the labor certification, evidence of the beneficiary's qualification and the employer's ability to pay.
Use the priority date and applicable Visa Bulletin chart to assess adjustment of status or immigrant visa processing. I-140 approval alone is not a green card.
THE IMMIGRANT PETITION
The filing should establish the requested classification, a valid basis for the labor certification requirement or exception, and eligibility as of the applicable filing dates.
PRECERTIFIED OCCUPATIONS
Schedule A is a labor certification route for designated occupations or qualifying workers. Instead of obtaining the ordinary PERM certification from DOL, the employer submits the required Schedule A labor certification materials to USCIS with Form I-140.
Qualifying professional nurses and physical therapists may use the Schedule A procedures when the required occupation specific credentials and filing documentation are satisfied. EB2 versus EB3 classification still depends on the offered position and the beneficiary's qualifications.
Schedule A Group II has distinct Department of Labor standards, including specific recognition requirements for exceptional ability in the sciences or arts and a separate performing arts framework. EB2 exceptional ability classification and Schedule A Group II are different legal tests.
A DIFFERENT PATH WITHIN EB2
Under the national interest waiver, the petitioner must first qualify for EB2 as an advanced degree professional or person of exceptional ability. USCIS then separately evaluates whether waiving the job offer and labor certification requirements is justified in the national interest.
The proposed endeavor must have substantial merit and national importance. Broad assertions about an important industry do not alone establish the significance of the specific endeavor.
The record should explain the person's qualifications, progress, resources, prior results and realistic ability to advance the proposed work.
USCIS considers whether, on balance, it would benefit the United States to waive a job offer and the related labor certification requirement.
CHOOSING THE CORRECT CLASSIFICATION
EB3 and EB2 are separate employment preference classifications. The appropriate category depends on the permanent position, the required credentials, the individual's qualifications and the intended petition route.
For an ordinary advanced degree petition, the labor certified job must require an advanced degree professional. Exceptional ability has its own eligibility test. Schedule A and NIW offer distinct routes where applicable.
EB3 professional roles generally require at least a bachelor's degree, and the other subcategories have their own standards. The offered position cannot be treated as EB2 merely because a preferred applicant has more education than the job requires.
FROM PETITION TO PERMANENT RESIDENCE
The process has two related but separate stages: approval of the immigrant petition and availability of an immigrant visa number for permanent residence.
For labor certification based cases, the priority date generally derives from the date DOL accepted the application for processing. For cases not requiring a labor certification, it ordinarily derives from proper filing of the I-140.
Where eligible, the beneficiary may file Form I-485 when the governing Visa Bulletin chart and USCIS monthly filing instructions permit it, subject to adjustment requirements and applicable bars and exceptions.
Qualifying beneficiaries abroad generally pursue consular processing after petition approval and visa availability, with the required National Visa Center and consular procedures.
COMMON RFE ISSUES
USCIS evaluates the particular legal requirement and evidence available at filing. The best response identifies the questioned element and supplies records that genuinely address it.
Generic verification letters may fail to establish a five year post degree progression in the specialty or compliance with the certified minimum requirements.
An advanced credential cannot cure a position that does not require an advanced degree professional, nor can it substitute for missing occupation qualifications.
Evidence satisfying three categories may be insufficient in the final merits analysis if the record does not establish expertise significantly above the normal level.
Payroll data, annual reports, tax returns and financial statements should support the ability to pay standard from the relevant priority date.
Job duties, minimum requirements, recruitment and the beneficiary's experience must be consistent with the certified labor market process.
Schedule A and NIW address different standards. A labor certification exception does not by itself establish eligibility for EB2 classification or permanent residence.
ILLUSTRATIVE SCENARIOS
These hypothetical examples explain classification decisions. They are not descriptions of client matters or guarantees of approval.
A company offers a permanent engineering position whose genuine minimum requirement is a qualifying advanced degree. The candidate has the relevant credentials, and the company assesses PERM requirements and ability to pay.
An applicant holds a qualifying bachelor's degree and documents at least five years of progressive post degree specialty experience. EB2 depends on whether the employer's certified role actually requires an advanced degree or regulatory equivalent.
A professional meets the underlying advanced degree or exceptional ability classification and proposes an endeavor with potential national importance. The NIW filing must independently address all three Dhanasar factors.
FREQUENT QUESTIONS
The classification, offered position and procedural route must be assessed together.
An individual who qualifies as an advanced degree professional or person of exceptional ability, and whose petition satisfies the job offer and labor certification rules or a valid waiver or exception.
No. In ordinary employer sponsored advanced degree cases, the permanent offered position must also require an advanced degree professional, and the worker must meet the certified minimum requirements.
A qualifying bachelor's degree or foreign equivalent followed by at least five years of progressive post baccalaureate specialty experience is treated as the equivalent of an advanced degree. The labor certified position must also support that minimum requirement in an ordinary petition.
The experience should reflect increasing responsibility, expertise, complexity or skill in the specialty. Detailed employer letters should explain the progression rather than merely listing dates.
Exceptional ability in the sciences, arts or business means expertise significantly above the ordinary level. USCIS requires evidence satisfying at least three of six categories and then evaluates the total record.
Not automatically. The initial criteria are a threshold. USCIS then determines whether the evidence as a whole establishes exceptional ability under the governing standard.
Yes, where the regulatory categories do not readily apply to the occupation, 8 CFR 204.5(k)(3)(iii) permits appropriate comparable evidence.
Most ordinary EB2 petitions require a qualifying employer and permanent job offer. A national interest waiver may waive the job offer and labor certification requirements when USCIS grants it.
No. Most ordinary employer sponsored cases need DOL labor certification. Schedule A uses different procedures, and an approved national interest waiver eliminates the job offer and labor certification requirements.
Ordinary job offer based EB2 petitions are employer filed. A person requesting a national interest waiver may self petition on Form I-140.
Schedule A permits qualifying employers to submit designated labor certification applications to USCIS rather than first seeking the ordinary DOL certification. It does not automatically establish EB2 preference eligibility.
No. Department of Labor Schedule A Group II applies a separate set of requirements. Meeting EB2 exceptional ability criteria does not automatically satisfy Schedule A Group II.
For advanced degree EB2 employer petitions, the job must require an advanced degree professional or equivalent. EB3 has different categories and minimum qualification standards. The appropriate classification depends on the actual job and applicant.
Where the job offer requirement applies, the employer generally must show it can pay the offered wage from the priority date until permanent residence. Different evidence may be acceptable under 8 CFR 204.5(g)(2).
It generally reflects when DOL accepted a labor certification application for processing, or the filing date of the I-140 when no labor certification is required. Priority dates help determine immigrant visa availability.
No. The person must separately obtain adjustment of status or an immigrant visa when a visa number is available and all applicable permanent residence requirements are met.
Yes. A person who satisfies an underlying EB2 classification and the separate national interest waiver standard may self petition without a permanent job offer or labor certification.
The response should address the exact questioned eligibility elements with authoritative documents, consistent employment evidence, and legal analysis tailored to the applicable EB2 filing route.
Selected authorities: INA 203(b)(2); 8 CFR 204.5(k), 8 CFR 204.5(g)(2); 20 CFR 656.5 and 656.15; Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016). See the USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5 for current interpretive guidance.
THE MESSERSMITH LAW FIRM, P.A.
Peter Messersmith has practiced US immigration law since 2002. The firm evaluates employment-based petitions against the governing classification requirements, the permanent position, the applicant's credentials and the necessary employer-sponsored filing process.
Review documented immigration matters in the firm's Immigration Approvals gallery. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.
CLIENT TESTIMONIALS
Clients recognize the firm's careful preparation, responsiveness, and commitment to finding the appropriate legal strategy for their immigration cases.
Throughout the process, Peter was knowledgeable, professional, and straightforward. His assistant, Jen, was also outstanding. She was always patient, responsive, and willing to answer my questions promptly, which made a very stressful immigration process much easier.
Peter is the best immigration attorney you can ask for. He guided me through the entire employment-based green card process, from the EB-2 NIW petition to receiving my green card.
Peter and Jen are very reachable and patient. They are detail-oriented and very knowledgeable. I really enjoy working with them! If you choose them, you will be in good hands.
From the very outset, Mr. Messersmith and his team exhibited a level of professionalism and dedication that exceeded my expectations.
I found Peter online but I have to say I’m so lucky to find Peter as my immigration lawyer. He is the best lawyer I’ve met before.
Peter and his team helped me get approved for both an NIW and EB1A (extra ordinary ability), which ultimately led to a green card.
We had a great experience working with Peter, he supported me and the family through the EB 1 and I 485 application process.
His team has fast and quick communication - typically you will get a response in 1 business day
Peter assisted me in filing a waiver in order to reapply for a student visa into the US. He was very knowledgeable about the different laws and procedures, and could always answer all of my many questions.
I am writing to express my deepest gratitude for the exceptional legal representation and support you provided during the challenging process of resolving the issue with my H-4 visa application.
Peter and his expert team helped me to take care of my wife's immigration case. They were super valuable, helpful, kind, and caring people.
Peter and team helped me get EB1A approved. Most of the lawyers I contacted would say my case is hard for EB1A, but Peter reviewed my CV and rightly advised during each step of the EB1 process. He also filed my NIW which got approved too.
Mr. Messersmith is very knowledgeable and methodical, and can work on cases that are complicated and not necessarily normal.
The Messersmith Law Firm is one of the finest law firm in the US.
Very professional and helpful. Messersmith Law Firm are the best Immigration Lawyers. Peter is very helpful and guides you all the way in all the documentation and filing.
He is quite professional and gave me a lot of advice.
Mr. Messersmith is the most excellent lawyer I have ever experienced, he has successfully helped me in three of my legal cases, I really appreciate it.
Very experienced to help me and my family successfully got the permanent resident cards, it's a good choice.
Best immigration attorney!
I liked Peter's calm, honest, and balanced approach to our very difficult immigration problem.
Went very smoothly. Very fast responses to my inquiries. Always sent me an email when a status would change.
Peter is great. I found him online and scheduled an interview with him, letting him review my CV.
The office of Mr. Peter did a great job preparing and submitting my application for a green card.
He was very quick to response and he explains everything clearly. He even checked my recommendation letters!
Extremely intelligent and committed team, highly effective, efficient and there to stand by you when you need them most.
These selected testimonials reflect individual client experiences. Results vary according to the facts and circumstances of each matter.
EXPERIENCED IMMIGRATION REPRESENTATION
The appropriate approach depends on the professional's background, the offered role, the employer's eligibility and the applicable immigrant visa requirements.